pal-e-docs

Review: Svelte promotion prep: @svelte-notes annotations

review-416-2026-03-26 Review

review ready
Project

Verdict: READY

Third review of board item #416 (Forgejo issue westside-app#96). Prior reviews: review-416-2026-03-25 (NEEDS_REFINEMENT), review-416-2026-03-26 rev1 (NEEDS_REFINEMENT). This review evaluates whether the two remaining findings were adequately addressed via the scope update comment posted on the Forgejo issue.

Template Completeness

  • [x] Type — Feature
  • [x] Lineage — references parent note westside-playground-overhaul
  • [x] Repo — present (forgejo_admin/westside-playground)
  • [x] User Story — present and well-formed
  • [x] Context — present, explains gap between existing @route/@auth annotations and missing @state/@svelte-notes
  • [x] File Targets — present with detailed example for tryouts.html and translation pattern table
  • [x] Acceptance Criteria — present (6 items, all grep-verifiable)
  • [x] Test Expectations — present (grep-based verification + explicit "no automated tests")
  • [x] Constraints — present (annotations only, no HTML/CSS/JS changes)
  • [x] Checklist — present
  • [x] Related — present (3 references)
All required sections for a Feature issue are present.

Traceability

  • [x] story:WS-S26 label — on board item, matches parent note
  • [x] story label mismatch — MITIGATED. Issue body still says story:agent-promote, but: (1) scope update comment explicitly corrects to story:WS-S26, (2) board item label (authoritative source for traceability) is correct. Body edit would be cleaner but is not a blocker.
  • [x] arch:landing-site label — correct, playground pages are the landing site component
  • [x] Forgejo issue — forgejo_admin/westside-app#96, open

File Targets

  • [x] All 27 HTML files exist in westside-playground — verified via ls
  • [x] 8 public pages already have @svelte-notes annotations (index, about, tryouts, teams, schedule, gear, staff, sponsors) — from PR #45 site-overhaul branch
  • [x] 19 authenticated pages remain without annotations — this IS the remaining scope per the scope update comment
  • [x] tryouts.html — has existing @route/@auth/@nav/@api/@state/@svelte-notes doc comment block
  • [x] gear.html — exists (created by #94, now closed)
  • [x] shared/app.js — contains initKQToggle, initFilterList, initTabs, initRegister, initTeams functions. Pages with JS interactivity identified for annotation.
File target scope is fully valid. All dependency pages exist.

Repo Placement

MITIGATED. The Forgejo issue is filed on forgejo_admin/westside-app (issue #96) but all work targets forgejo_admin/westside-playground. The ### Repo section in the issue body correctly says forgejo_admin/westside-playground. The scope update comment explicitly states: "Agent should clone westside-playground, not westside-app." Refiling would break issue number references across 3 review comments, the board item, and dependency labels on sibling tickets. The mitigation is adequate — agents following the template structure read ### Repo for clone targets, not the issue's repo URL.

Dependencies

Board item labels: depends:ws-91+ws-92+ws-93+ws-94+ws-95 (removed from board item labels since all resolved)
  • [x] #91 (About page) — closed
  • [x] #92 (Tryouts page) — closed
  • [x] #93 (Teams page) — closed
  • [x] #94 (Gear page) — closed
  • [x] #95 (Schedule update) — closed
All 5 dependencies closed. No blocking dependencies remain.

Acceptance Criteria

All 6 criteria are mechanically verifiable via grep. The translation pattern table provides a concrete mapping from HTML patterns to Svelte 5 equivalents. An agent can verify each criterion after implementation. No issues.

Blast Radius

Low blast radius. Documentation-only changes (HTML comments). No functional code, CSS, or JS is modified. No sibling services affected. 8 public pages already annotated (PR #45) provide a working pattern for the remaining 19 authenticated pages.
Minor staleness risk: translation patterns reference basketball-api endpoint signatures that could change before Svelte promotion. Acceptable for documentation.

Prior Review Delta

Finding Rev 1 Status Rev 2 Status Rev 3 Status
Repo placement mismatch OPEN STILL OPEN <strong>MITIGATED</strong> — comment clarifies clone target, ### Repo section correct
Story label mismatch OPEN STILL OPEN <strong>MITIGATED</strong> — board item label correct, comment corrects body text
Dependencies #93, #94, #95 open BLOCKING RESOLVED RESOLVED
gear.html missing BLOCKING RESOLVED RESOLVED

Scope Note

PR #45 (site-overhaul) has already annotated 8 public pages. The remaining scope for this ticket is 19 authenticated pages. The scope update comment on the Forgejo issue documents this clearly. If PR #45 merges before this ticket is worked, the agent will find the public page annotations already in place and only need to handle authenticated pages. If PR #45 has not merged, the agent handles all 27 pages. Either way the ticket scope is correct.

Recommendation

No action needed. Ticket is READY for todo → next_up. Two cosmetic improvements are optional (not blocking):
  • Optional: Edit the issue body to change story:agent-promote to story:WS-S26 for consistency.
  • Optional: Add a note at the top of the issue body: "Note: This issue is filed on westside-app but targets westside-playground. See ### Repo section."