pal-e-docs

Review: Move kanban prototype from pal-e-playground

review-320-2026-03-24 Review

review ready
Project

Verdict: READY

Re-review after refinements posted in comment #6584. All three original NEEDS_REFINEMENT issues resolved.

Template Completeness

  • [x] Type
  • [x] Lineage
  • [x] Repo
  • [x] User Story
  • [x] Context
  • [x] File Targets (updated in refinement comment)
  • [x] Acceptance Criteria (augmented in refinement comment)
  • [x] Test Expectations
  • [x] Constraints
  • [x] Checklist
  • [x] Related

Refinement Resolution

Original Issue Status Evidence
Cross-repo scope (pal-e-playground cleanup in svelte-playground ticket) FIXED Split into <code>forgejo_admin/pal-e-playground#9</code> — confirmed issue exists with proper scope (remove pal-e-app/ dir, update hub index)
Hub card language ("add card" vs "convert existing") FIXED Refinement comment clarifies: "convert existing Coming Soon div to a working link"
Missing acceptance criteria (hub card link, shared.css reference) FIXED Two new ACs added in refinement comment: hub card links to /pal-e-app/ with badge removed; index.html references /shared.css

File Targets

Verified against refinement comment's updated file targets (svelte-playground only):
  • [x] pal-e-playground/pal-e-app/index.html — verified source exists, 30 lines, Svelte 5 mount point. References /app.css which agent must change to /shared.css
  • [x] pal-e-playground/pal-e-app/board.svelte — verified source exists, 368 lines. Uses var(--color-text-faint) via inline styles (no CSS imports). shared.css provides this token.
  • [x] svelte-playground/vite.config.js — verified exists, currently only main: resolve(__dirname, 'index.html'). Needs pal-e-app entry added.
  • [x] svelte-playground/index.html — verified exists. Line 146-149: <div class="card"> with "Coming Soon" badge. Agent must convert to <a href="/pal-e-app/" class="card"> and remove badge.
  • [x] svelte-playground/shared.css — verified exists, contains --color-text-faint (line 15) which board.svelte depends on
  • [x] svelte-playground/pal-e-app/ — confirmed does NOT yet exist (correct — target directory to create)
No pal-e-playground file targets remain in scope (moved to pal-e-playground#9).

Repo Placement

OK. Issue is filed on forgejo_admin/svelte-playground. All file targets are within svelte-playground. Cross-repo cleanup correctly split to forgejo_admin/pal-e-playground#9.

Dependencies

  • Board item #319 ("Scaffold repo with hub + shared CSS") — done column. Prerequisite satisfied.
  • Board item #321 ("Deploy with Tailscale funnel") — backlog column. Not blocked by or blocking this ticket.
  • forgejo_admin/pal-e-playground#9 (cleanup) — independent. Can run after this ticket completes but is not a blocker.
  • Lineage states "Depends on: repo scaffold" — correctly documented and verified satisfied.

Acceptance Criteria

Combined original + refinement ACs:
  • [x] "npm run dev serves kanban board at localhost:5173/pal-e-app/" — testable, agent can verify
  • [x] "Drag-and-drop works between columns" — testable with Playwright or manual
  • [x] "Filter pills filter by type" — testable
  • [x] "Child drill-down expands inline" — testable
  • [x] "Hub card links to /pal-e-app/ with Coming Soon badge removed" — testable (added in refinement)
  • [x] "pal-e-app/index.html references /shared.css instead of /app.css" — testable (added in refinement)
The original AC "pal-e-playground no longer has pal-e-app/ directory" is superseded by refinement comment — belongs to pal-e-playground#9.

Blast Radius

Low. No external references to pal-e-playground/pal-e-app/ found in pal-e-app, pal-e-docs, or other repos. No downstream consumers affected.

Advisory

The refinements live in a comment (comment #6584), not in the edited issue body. The issue body still contains the old File Targets (with pal-e-playground cleanup) and the old acceptance criteria (missing two items, including one cross-repo AC). An agent reading the full thread will see both the original body and the refinement comment — the comment is clear and unambiguous. No action required, but if the body is edited to incorporate refinements before agent dispatch, it would eliminate any ambiguity.

Recommendation

No action needed. Ticket is READY for agent dispatch. All three original refinement items resolved. Cross-repo scope properly split. File targets verified against codebase.