pal-e-docs

Review: Doc: Auth architecture on project page (re-review)

review-268-2026-03-27-v2 Review

review ready
Project

Verdict: READY

Template Completeness

  • [x] Type -- Feature
  • [x] Lineage -- plan-wkq Phase 11
  • [x] Repo -- forgejo_admin/basketball-api (docs only)
  • [x] User Story -- As a platform operator...
  • [x] Context -- Gmail OAuth decision, Keycloak admin/account console discovery
  • [x] File Targets -- arch-auth-westside-basketball note (add subsections)
  • [x] Acceptance Criteria -- 5 items, all verifiable
  • [x] Test Expectations -- get_section calls against correct note slug
  • [x] Constraints -- Update arch note, not project page
  • [x] Checklist -- Present
  • [x] Related -- basketball-api #132, #144
  • [x] Review History -- Documents prior review fixes

Traceability

  • [ ] story:WS-S1 label -- MISMATCH. WS-S1 is IaC deployment, not auth. Issue body explicitly flags this for Betty Sue: should be WS-S3 (Keycloak) or WS-S12 (user account mgmt). Board item label needs update.
  • [x] arch:auth label -- Present on board item. Correct for auth documentation work.
  • [x] Forgejo issue -- basketball-api #145, open. Valid.

File Targets

  • [x] pal-e-docs note arch-auth-westside-basketball -- verified: note exists (id 560), has 8 subsections (Identity Provider, Roles, Two Auth Patterns, Keycloak Clients, Account Creation, API Auth, Token Flow, Related). Neither "Auth Management Paths" nor "Key Decisions" subsections exist yet -- confirmed via TOC. Target is correct.
  • [x] NOT touching project-westside-basketball -- explicitly stated. Correct per first review finding.

Repo Placement

Mild mismatch: issue filed on basketball-api but work is a pal-e-docs note update. Issue body acknowledges this with "(docs only -- pal-e-docs note update)". Acceptable -- the auth architecture conceptually lives with basketball-api. No code files touched.

Dependencies

No blocking dependencies. Related items (basketball-api #132 custom password reset, #144 Marcus admin access) are both done. All Phase 11 auth work is complete. This ticket captures the documentation gap discovered during that work. No items depend on this ticket.

Acceptance Criteria

5 AC, all agent-verifiable via pal-e-docs API:
  • AC 1-2: Subsection existence -- verifiable via get_section
  • AC 3: Three auth paths documented -- verifiable by reading content
  • AC 4: Key URLs and roles -- verifiable by reading content
  • AC 5: Gmail OAuth decision recorded -- verifiable by reading content
Test expectations correctly target get_section(slug="arch-auth-westside-basketball", anchor_id="auth-management-paths") and get_section(slug="arch-auth-westside-basketball", anchor_id="key-decisions"). Both are real, testable API calls.

Blast Radius

Minimal. One pal-e-docs note, no code changes, no sibling services affected. Other westside architecture notes (domain, dataflow, deployment, sitemap) are unaffected. No downstream consumers.

Decomposition

1 file target, 0 repos (docs only), 5 AC, estimated 2-3 minutes. No decomposition needed.

Recommendation

  • [LABEL] Betty Sue: Update board item #268 story label from story:WS-S1 to story:WS-S3 (or story:WS-S12). The issue body explicitly requests this change.
After label fix, ticket is ready to move todo to next_up.

Prior Review History

First review (review-268-2026-03-27) found 4 issues: wrong file target, story label mismatch, missing arch label, wrong test expectation. Re-review after refinement: 3 of 4 fixed in issue body. arch:auth was already present. Only the board item story label remains.