Review: Spike: Mobile framework decision
Verdict: READY
Template Completeness
Validated against
template-issue-spike.- [x] Type — Spike
- [x] Lineage — Related to
ldraney/kalshi-assistant #6(parent issue). Decision gate for all mobile app work in sprint 4. - [x] Repo —
ldraney/kalshi-assistant - [x] Question — Main question with 5 sub-questions covering Rails+Turbo Native+Capacitor, PWA, React Native/Flutter, secure storage, and developer velocity
- [x] Deliverables — 3 deliverables: ADR doc, follow-up ticket updates, decision record
- [x] Time-box — 1 session, with escalation path
- [x] Related — Project and parent issue linked
Traceability
- [x] story:app-experience label — App Experience
- [x] story note verified —
story-kalshi-assistant-app-experiencefound in project-kalshi-assistant user-stories section - [x] arch:frontend label — Frontend
- [x] arch note verified —
arch-frontendnote exists in pal-e-docs (title: "Frontend: kalshi-assistant", status: active) - [x] Forgejo issue —
ldraney/kalshi-assistant #13, open
File Targets
- [x]
docs/architecture/mobile-framework-adr.md— target deliverable. Directorydocs/architecture/does not exist yet; will be created as part of the spike. Parentdocs/exists. Appropriate for a spike that produces docs.
Repo Placement
OK. Issue filed on
ldraney/kalshi-assistant, matches ### Repo field. Single-repo investigation.Dependencies
- Parent: #1691 (issue #6) "Mobile app — API key connection and strategy dashboard" (backlog, sprint 4, 8pts) — documented in Lineage
- Downstream sprint 4 frontend items blocked by this decision:
- No items in
in_progressblock this spike - Dependencies documented in issue Lineage section: "Decision gate for all mobile app work in sprint 4"
Acceptance Criteria
Spike uses Deliverables instead of Acceptance Criteria (per template). Assessment:
docs/architecture/mobile-framework-adr.mdcreated — verifiable by file existence and ADR content check- Follow-up ticket file targets updated — verifiable by checking issue #6 children for revised file paths
- Team decision recorded with rationale — verifiable by ADR content inspection (somewhat redundant with deliverable 1, but acceptable)
All deliverables are agent-verifiable.
Blast Radius
- Decision affects all 5 sprint 4 frontend items (all currently in backlog)
- No existing code in the repo (docs only) — no breaking changes possible
- Note:
arch-frontendalready documents "Turbo Native iOS shell wrapping Rails views with Capacitor native bridge". This spike may confirm or revise that assumption. No conflict — spikes are intended for exactly this kind of validation. - No sibling services or downstream consumers affected
Decomposition Assessment
No decomposition needed.
- File targets: 1 docs file
- Deliverables: 3 (all part of single investigation)
- Repos: 1
- Estimated work: 1 session (within time-box)
Recommendation
No action needed.