Review: docs: update docs/ for consolidation and codify sprint philosophy (round 2)
Verdict: APPROVED
Round 2 re-review of board item #1571. Round 1 (
review-1571-2026-06-22) found incorrect file targets. The issue body has been updated with all corrections. This review verifies the fixes.Template Completeness
- [x] Type -- Feature
- [x] Lineage -- present, references PR #60 as upstream
- [x] Repo -- ldraney/paldocs
- [x] User Story -- present
- [x] Context -- thorough, explains both stale docs and sprint philosophy with DORA rationale
- [x] File Targets -- present, all corrected from round 1
- [x] Feature Flag -- none, docs-only, appropriate
- [x] Acceptance Criteria -- 6 criteria, all clear and verifiable
- [x] Test Expectations -- 2 items, appropriate for docs
- [x] Constraints -- present
- [x] Checklist -- present, matches all file targets
- [x] Related -- present, includes project page, arch note, story, upstream/downstream
Traceability
- [x] story:sprint-orchestration label -- present on board item
- [x] story note verified --
story-paldocs-sprint-orchestrationfound inproject-paldocsuser-stories section - [x] arch:docs label -- present on board item
- [ ] arch note MISSING -- [SCOPE] No
arch-docsnote found in pal-e-docs. Create architecture notearch-docsfor the docs component. (Carried from round 1 -- this is external to the issue body and does not block the ticket.) - [x] Forgejo issue -- ldraney/paldocs#67, open
File Targets
- [x]
README.md-- verified: exists at/home/ldraney/paldocs/README.md. Stale references confirmed at lines 3, 12, 19, 20, 42, 79. Line 79 has "No Rails-managed migrations" claim. Line 20 references pal-e-docs FastAPI as coexisting. - [x]
docs/data-model.md-- verified: exists. Stale references at lines 3, 134-137 (schema managed externally, DDL managed by FastAPI). CORRECTED from round 1 (wasdocs/shared-database.md). - [x]
docs/infrastructure.md-- verified: exists. Stale references at lines 61, 64 (external shared database managed by pal-e-docs FastAPI). CORRECTED from round 1 (wasdocs/architecture.md). - [x]
docs/auth-visibility-architecture.md-- verified: exists. Stale Alembic references at lines 58, 126. Additional pal-e-docs references throughout (lines 7, 19, 22, 24, 40, 49, 53, 55, 67, etc.). ADDED in round 2 per round 1 recommendation. - [x]
docs/sprint-philosophy.md-- verified: does NOT exist yet (expected -- ticket says NEW).
"Files NOT touched" verification:
docs/user-stories.md confirmed to have zero stale schema references. Correct to exclude.Round 1 Fixes Verified
- [x]
[BODY]docs/shared-database.mdcorrected todocs/data-model.md-- verified in File Targets and AC2 - [x]
[BODY]docs/architecture.mdcorrected todocs/infrastructure.md-- verified in File Targets and AC3 - [x]
[BODY]AC2 updated to referencedocs/data-model.md-- verified - [x]
[BODY]AC3 updated to referencedocs/infrastructure.md-- verified - [x]
[BODY]docs/auth-visibility-architecture.mdadded to File Targets -- verified, with dedicated AC4 - [ ]
[SCOPE]Create arch-docs note -- still outstanding (does not block ticket, see below)
Repo Placement
OK. Issue filed on ldraney/paldocs, all file targets are in the paldocs repo. Single-repo, docs-only change. No cross-repo work needed.
Dependencies
- Upstream (completed): paldocs#49 (schema ownership transfer) -- merged as PR #60. This is what created the stale docs.
- Downstream: paldocs#50 (sprint schema, in next_up) -- the sprint philosophy doc should inform #50's design. No hard blocker, but logical ordering is correct.
- No blockers from in_progress items. No items currently in_progress on board-paldocs.
Acceptance Criteria
6 acceptance criteria. All verifiable by grep/read:
- AC1: grep README for pal-e-api DDL references -- verifiable
- AC2: grep data-model.md for Alembic references -- verifiable
- AC3: grep infrastructure.md for stale ownership claims -- verifiable
- AC4: grep auth-visibility-architecture.md for stale pal-e-docs/Alembic references -- verifiable
- AC5: file existence check + content verification for sprint-philosophy.md -- verifiable
- AC6: recursive grep across all docs for stale references -- verifiable (catch-all)
All criteria are machine-verifiable. No ambiguity.
Blast Radius
Stale references confirmed in 4 existing files:
README.md-- 6 lines with stale referencesdocs/data-model.md-- 3 lines (lines 3, 134, 137)docs/infrastructure.md-- 2 lines (lines 61, 64)docs/auth-visibility-architecture.md-- 2 explicit Alembic lines (58, 126) plus many pal-e-docs references throughout. Note: many pal-e-docs references in this file are about the Keycloak realm name (pal-e-docsrealm), which is still valid and should NOT be removed. The agent must distinguish between stale schema ownership references and valid realm name references.
docs/user-stories.md confirmed clean -- no stale references.Decomposition Assessment
5 file targets in 1 repo. 6 acceptance criteria (marginally above 5-AC guideline). All docs-only, no code changes. Estimated agent work: 3-5 minutes. No decomposition needed. The 6th AC is a catch-all grep that naturally follows from fixing the other 4 files.
Recommendation
[SCOPE]Create architecture notearch-docsin pal-e-docs for the docs component. (Carried from round 1 -- does not block ticket advancement. Can be done in parallel or after.)
All
[BODY] recommendations from round 1 have been addressed. Ticket is ready for implementation.